Skip to main content
Home
EV Stories

Main navigation

  • Home
  • Cars
  • Vans
  • Trucks
  • News
User account menu
  • Contact

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Porsche
  3. E-fuels: A Controversial Alternative to Electric Vehicles in Europe

E-fuels: A Controversial Alternative to Electric Vehicles in Europe

E-fuels: A Controversial Alternative to Electric Vehicles in Europe

The European Union (EU) plans to ban the sale of new combustion engine vehicles from 2035 as part of its ambitious climate goals. However, not everyone agrees with this decision, especially Germany, which is home to some of the world's largest carmakers. Germany's Minister for Digital Affairs and Transport, Volker Wissing (FDP), is trying to prevent the EU from banning the use of e-fuels for most combustion engines - and thus soften the complete ban on combustion engines.

E-fuels are synthetic fuels that are produced from renewable or decarbonized electricity and capture carbon dioxide or carbon monoxide. Some see them as a way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from transport, particularly for long-distance freight, marine, and air transport, which are difficult to electrify. However, e-fuels also face many challenges and criticisms, such as their high cost, low efficiency, and uncertain environmental impact. The car manufacturers have fundamentally different views on the subject of e-fuel – we asked around who was in favor and who was against.

First image gallery
E-fuels
E-fuels

What are the arguments for e-fuels?

The main argument for e-fuels is that they can be used as drop-in replacement fuels for existing combustion engines without requiring major vehicle or infrastructure changes. This means that e-fuels can leverage the existing fleet of cars, trucks, ships, and planes and the existing network of fuel stations and refineries. This would avoid the need to scrap millions of vehicles and invest billions of euros in new charging stations and battery factories.

Another argument for e-fuels is that they can offer a higher energy density and range than batteries, which still need to be improved by their weight and size. This makes e-fuels more suitable for heavy-duty vehicles and long-distance travel, where batteries may need to be able to provide more power or autonomy. E-fuels can also be stored more easily than electricity, which requires complex grid management and storage systems.

A third argument for e-fuels is that they can be produced from renewable or decarbonized electricity sources, such as wind, solar, or nuclear power. This means that e-fuels can be carbon-neutral or even carbon-negative if they use carbon dioxide captured from the atmosphere or from industrial plants that use fossil fuels. E-fuels can thus reduce greenhouse gas emissions from transport, accounting for about a quarter of global CO2 emissions.

Who is in favor of e-fuels?

Some carmakers supporting e-fuels are BMW, Porsche, Audi, and Volkswagen. These companies have invested in the research and development of e-fuels, as well as in pilot projects and partnerships to produce and test e-fuels. For example, Porsche has invested in the Haru Oni project in Chile, which aims to create synthetic methanol from wind power. Audi is working on e-diesel and e-gasoline projects, while Volkswagen is collaborating with Siemens and other partners to develop e-fuels for maritime transport.

These carmakers argue that e-fuels can complement electric vehicles and offer more choice and flexibility to customers. They also claim that e-fuels can preserve the heritage and performance of their brands, which are known for their powerful and sporty combustion engines. They believe that e-fuels can be a viable solution for the transition to a low-carbon economy, especially for segments where electrification is not feasible or desirable.

Who is against e-fuels?

Some of the carmakers that oppose e-fuels are Tesla, Renault, Volvo, and Ford. These companies have focused on developing and promoting electric vehicles as the only way to achieve zero-emission mobility. They have invested heavily in battery technology, charging infrastructure, and software services to make electric vehicles more attractive and convenient for customers. They also benefit from the regulatory incentives and subsidies that favor electric vehicles over other alternatives.

These carmakers argue that e-fuels are too expensive, inefficient, and uncertain to be a realistic option for decarbonizing transport. They point out that producing e-fuels requires a lot of energy and resources, which could be better used for generating electricity or making batteries. They also question the availability and sustainability of the electricity sources and the carbon capture methods that are needed for making e-fuels. They contend that electric vehicles are already cheaper, cleaner, and more reliable than combustion engines and that they will continue to improve in terms of performance, range, and safety.

What is the EU's position on e-fuels?

The EU has proposed a new regulation to phase out the sale of new combustion engine vehicles from 2035 to achieve its climate targets. The regulation would also set stricter emission standards for new vehicles until then, requiring them to reduce their CO2 emissions by 55% by 2030 and by 100% by 2035 compared to 2021 levels.

However, the regulation would allow some exceptions for certain types of vehicles that use e-fuels or other low-carbon fuels. These include heavy-duty vehicles such as buses, trucks, and coaches, as well as off-road vehicles such as tractors and construction machines. These vehicles would have to reduce their CO2 emissions by 50% by 2030 and by 75% by 2035 compared to 2021 levels. The regulation would also allow some flexibility for niche markets such as sports cars and motorcycles, which could use e-fuels or other low-carbon fuels to meet the emission standards.

The EU's compromise proposal is meant to balance the interests of different member states and stakeholders and ensure a fair and feasible transition to a carbon-neutral transport sector. However, the proposal still faces opposition from some countries and groups that want to preserve the combustion engine industry or promote other alternatives such as hydrogen or biofuels. The final decision will depend on the negotiations between the European Parliament, the European Council, and the European Commission, which is expected to take place in the coming months.

What are the implications of e-fuels for the future of green mobility?

E-fuels are a controversial and complex topic that involves technical, economic, environmental, and political aspects. They have the potential to offer a solution for the future of green mobility, but they also face many challenges and uncertainties. They could be a way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from transport, especially for segments that are hard to electrify, but they could also be a distraction or a delay from the necessary shift to electric vehicles. They could be a way to preserve the combustion engine industry and its jobs. Still, they could also be a threat to the innovation and competitiveness of the electric vehicle industry.

Second image gallery
E-fuels

The future of e-fuels will depend on several factors, such as the availability and cost of renewable or decarbonized electricity sources, the development and deployment of carbon capture technologies, the regulation and taxation of different types of vehicles and fuels, the consumer preferences and behavior regarding mobility options, and the collaboration and competition among different carmakers and countries. E-fuels are not a silver bullet or a magic solution for green mobility, but they could be part of a diversified and integrated approach that considers multiple pathways and scenarios for achieving a low-carbon transport system.

Brand

  • Porsche
  • Ford

Category

  • News

Tags

  • Greenhouse gas emissions
  • Carbon neutrality
  • Electrofuel
  • Climate change
  • Low-carbon fuel
  • Low-carbon economy
  • Electric vehicles
  • Electric battery
  • E-fuels
  • European market
  • Add new comment
avatar
By EV stories, 24 March, 2023

Similar stories

Ford and Lexie Alford embark on a historic adventure with the electric Explorer

A century ago, a daring woman named Aloha Wanderwell made history by becoming the first woman to drive around the world in a car. She traveled through 43 countries on her Ford Model… Continue reading...

Ford and Lexie Alford embark on a historic adventure with the electric Explorer

California Leads the Way in EV Transition with 2035 Ban on Gasoline Vehicles

California is accelerating the transition to electric vehicles (EVs) by banning the sale of new gasoline-powered cars and trucks by 2035. Governor Gavin Newsom signed an executive… Continue reading...

California Leads the Way in EV Transition with 2035 Ban on Gasoline Vehicles

Nissan and Bilia team up to boost electric vehicle sales in Sweden

Nissan, one of the world's leading automakers, has announced a new partnership with Bilia, Sweden's largest car dealership chain, to strengthen their collaboration… Continue reading...

Nissan ARIYA

Volvo commits to becoming carbon neutral by 2040

The targets that Volvo has set for electric mobility have been reinforced. "Despite the enormous challenges we faced throughout the year, we made great headway toward achieving our… Continue reading...

 Volvo EX90

BMW boosts Oxford plant as it gears up for more Mini electric cars

BMW is set to invest up to £600m in its Mini plant near Oxford to prepare it for producing more electric vehicles. The firm is expected to announce the investment soon, which will… Continue reading...

BMW boosts Oxford plant as it gears up for more Mini electric cars

Toyota Accelerates Its Electrification Plans with U.S. BEV Production and Battery Plant Investment

Toyota is ramping up its commitment to electrification with plans to produce its first battery electric vehicle (BEV) in the U.S. and invest in additional battery… Continue reading...

Toyota Accelerates Its Electrification Plans with U.S. BEV Production and Battery Plant Investment

Europe's electric vehicle sales may soon face a reality check

Sales of battery electric vehicles are growing in Europe, primarily due to the excitement of wealthy early adopters and government incentives. Still, for the electric car revolution… Continue reading...

Europe's electric vehicle sales may soon face a reality check

Ford wants a future powered by electric vehicles

When it comes to the fight for an all-electric future, Ford is in the front. Ford has just been one of the 27 corporations that have come together in favor of European regulations on… Continue reading...

BlueOval Charge Network

Hertz and Polestar want to speed up the introduction of electric cars

Hertz and Polestar have formed a global strategic partnership to speed up the introduction of electric cars. Hertz and Polestar (the Swedish company that makes high-performance… Continue reading...

Polestar 2 electric car

Jeep brand in Europe has a new CEO

Eric Laforge will take over management of the Jeep brand in Europe on February 1, 2023. Antonella Bruno, who was in charge of the Peugeot brand in the same region, has been replaced… Continue reading...

Jeep brand in Europe has a new CEO
Porsche Taycan Turbo S - Formula E's new safety car

Porsche Taycan Turbo S - Formula E's new safety car

Like us!

EV stories

Latest news

Toyota Accelerates Its Electrification Plans with U.S. BEV Production and Battery Plant Investment

Toyota Accelerates Its Electrification Plans with U.S. BEV Production and Battery Plant Investment

Kia EV9: A Bold Step Towards Scalable Sustainability

Kia EV9: A Bold Step Towards Scalable Sustainability

The 2024 BMW i5 M60 xDrive is a fully-electric 5 Series that doesn't compromise on performance

he 2024 BMW i5 M60 xDrive is a fully-electric 5 Series that doesn't compromise on performance

BMW i7 shines at the 76th Cannes Film Festival

BMW i7 shines at the 76th Cannes Film Festival

The 2023 Audi SQ8 e-tron Is the Ultimate Electric SUV for Driving Enthusiasts

The 2023 Audi SQ8 e-tron Is the Ultimate Electric SUV for Driving Enthusiasts

Volvo EX30: The Safest Electric Car on the Market

Volvo EX30: The Safest Electric Car on the Market

2023 Ford E‑Tourneo Courier: The Perfect Electric Van for Small Businesses and Families

2023 Ford E‑Tourneo Courier: The Perfect Electric Van for Small Businesses and Families

Iveco's Bold Move: Taking Over Nikola in Europe

Iveco's Bold Move: Taking Over Nikola in Europe

The 2023 Volvo EX90 is a stunning electric SUV that delivers on sound and design

The 2023 Volvo EX90 is a stunning electric SUV that delivers on sound and design

Skoda Enyaq Coupe 80 Premium: A Stylish and Practical Electric SUV

Skoda Enyaq Coupe 80 Premium

Partners

»Panorica  »Car division  »Junk Car Removal in Toronto GTA

Popular stories

The new YOYO electric quadricycle with a range of 160 kilometers

XEV YOYO electric city car

Kia EV9: The Family-Friendly Electric SUV That Keeps You Comfortable in Any Climate

Kia EV9: The Family-Friendly Electric SUV That Keeps You Comfortable in Any Climate

The new Elaris Beo electric SUV from China comes to Germany

The new Elaris Beo electric SUV

The US government intends to support electric vehicles heavily

United States government

The new Mia 2.0 will be priced at about 16,000 euros

Mia Electric car

The Opel Astra electric car will be available from 2023

Opel Astra

Zeekr X: The Affordable and Stylish Electric Hatchback from China

Zeekr X

The new BMW iX electric SUV in Phytonic Blue Metallic

BMW iX electric SUV

A new electric era for Koreans: Hyundai IONIQ 5

Hyundai IONIQ 5 electric car

The BMW i7 M70 xDrive Will Revolutionize the Electric Luxury Sedan Market

BMW i7 M70 xDrive
Ford
Polestar
Volkswagen
BMW
Renault
Hyundai
Audi
Mercedes-Benz
Skoda
Opel
Jeep
Volvo
Fiat
Citroen
Tesla
Toyota
RSS feed

evstories.com · 2023 · Privacy Policy · Powered by Contabo VPS

Powered by Drupal